top of page

Matt Walsh Says Neurodivergence Isn't Real. Let's Discuss

Writer: Kaitlyn Borris
Kaitlyn Borris
Nov 9
7 min read



Every so often, the internet gives us a reminder that just because someone speaks confidently into a camera doesn't mean they're saying something scientifically accurate.


Recently, I came across a reel making the argument that neurodivergence isn't real. Maybe you saw it. Matt Walsh, host of the Matt Walsh show on The Daily Wire and frequent poster of controversial pseudo-scientific statements, claimed that neurodivergence isn't...real. He claims it is a new fangled umbrella term, and throws in plenty of derogatory terms in there too. If you haven't seen it? Don't. It's false science and mumbo-jumbo (which is totally a scientific term).



Is Neurodivergence Real?


Let's start with something important: Neurodivergence is not a formal medical or psychiatric diagnosis. But that does not mean neurological differences aren't "real".


Those are two entirely different arguments, and confusing them does a disservice to the people and families navigating these very real differences every day.



First, What Does Neurodivergence Actually Mean?


The term neurodiversity describes the natural variation in how human brains function. People learn differently, process information differently, communicate differently, experience sensory information differently, and navigate the world differently.


Neurodivergence is commonly used as an umbrella term to describe individuals whose neurological functioning differs from what is considered typical - this part Matt Walsh actually has right, to a degree. It is an umbrella term.


This can include individuals with:


- Autism spectrum disorder

- Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)

- Dyslexia

- Dyscalculia

- Dyspraxia

- Tourette syndrome

- Other neurological and developmental differences


There is no universally accepted clinical definition of neurodivergence, and the term itself is not listed as a diagnosis in the DSM.


That's okay.


Not every meaningful term used to describe human experiences needs to be a diagnostic category. And, even though we might see it in the DSM one day, it doesn't really matter if it's in there today. Complex PTSD is not in the DSM, but most therapists will tell you it's a real thing.


We have plenty of language that helps us communicate about experiences, identities, and differences without functioning as a medical diagnosis.


The absence of a diagnostic label does not negate the existence of the experience being described.



Let's Talk About the Actual Science.


If we want to have a conversation about whether neurodivergence is real, let's look at the conditions commonly described under that umbrella.


Autism is a recognized neurodevelopmental condition. It involves differences in social communication, interaction, behavior, and sensory processing.


ADHD is a recognized neurodevelopmental disorder that can affect attention, impulsivity, activity levels, and executive functioning.


Dyslexia is a recognized learning disability that affects reading and can involve difficulties with phonological processing, spelling, and reading fluency.


These aren't simply personality quirks. They aren't trends. They aren't something someone invented because they wanted to feel different.


They are well-established conditions with documented effects on how individuals learn, communicate, process information, and function in everyday environments.


We can debate terminology all day long, but we shouldn't confuse a debate about terminology with a debate about whether these conditions exist. Would Matt Walsh debate the existence of personality disorders because we lump them under an umbrella? What about eating disorders, or anxiety disorders? Those are broad categories thatwe use to classify specific symptoms. Why should Neurodivergence be any different?



Just Because You Can't See the Struggle Doesn't Mean It Isn't There.


Here's something I think gets lost in these conversations especially about Neurodivergence.


Two children can sit in the same classroom, receive the same instructions, have the same teacher, and be given the exact same assignment.


One child completes the assignment without much difficulty.


The other child spends considerably more time trying to process the instructions, organize their thoughts, decode the words, regulate their emotions, and figure out where to begin.


From the outside, someone might see a child who is distracted, unmotivated, behind, difficult, or simply not trying hard enough.


But what if that's not what's happening?


What if the child is working incredibly hard just to accomplish something that comes more naturally to their peers?


What if reading takes substantially more effort? What if background noise makes concentration nearly impossible? What if transitions feel overwhelming? What if the child understands the material but struggles to demonstrate that understanding in a traditional classroom setting?


Different doesn't mean incapable. And struggling doesn't mean someone isn't trying.


This is one of the reasons understanding neurodevelopmental differences matters so much.


When we understand how someone processes information, we can stop assuming that everyone should be able to learn, communicate, and function using the same approach.


...And no, Matt. It's not simply "being an introvert".



The Danger of Dismissing Neurodivergence


When we dismiss neurodivergence as something that isn't real, we risk reinforcing some pretty harmful assumptions.


We risk telling parents that their child's struggles are exaggerated.


We risk telling children indirectly that they're simply not trying hard enough.


We risk overlooking learning disabilities because a child doesn't fit someone's preconceived idea of what a learning disability looks like.


We risk interpreting sensory overwhelm as bad behavior, executive functioning difficulties as laziness, and communication differences as disrespect.


And perhaps most importantly, we risk making people feel like they have to work harder to appear typical rather than learning how to work with the way their brains function.


There is a difference between helping someone develop skills and expecting them to constantly compensate for an environment that doesn't accommodate their needs.


We can encourage growth without demanding that everyone function identically.


Neurodiversity Doesn't Mean Pretending Disability Doesn't Exist.


I also want to address something else.


Sometimes, discussions about neurodiversity get interpreted as suggesting that neurological differences are always positive, that disability shouldn't be acknowledged, or that people shouldn't need support.


That's not what neurodiversity has to mean.


We can celebrate someone's strengths while acknowledging their challenges.


We can recognize that autism is part of someone's identity while also recognizing that autism can create significant support needs.


We can appreciate the creativity, unique perspectives, and strengths that some neurodivergent individuals experience without pretending that navigating an inaccessible world is easy.


We can embrace neurodiversity AND advocate for accommodations, educational support, therapies, interventions, and resources.


In fact, those things should go hand in hand.


Acceptance should never mean abandoning support. It also doesn't mean that every behavior should be tolerated or allowed. If

a child with autism is throwing desks at school, clearly that is a safety issue and behavior that cannot continue. Ironically, I don't think any parent with a neurodiverse child is saying that - it seems to always come from people who's lived experience with Neurodivergence comes exclusively from social media.




A Personal Perspective: Sometimes, You Have to Look a Little Closer.


One thing I've learned is that children's struggles aren't always obvious.


Sometimes, a child who appears to be avoiding reading is actually experiencing significant difficulty decoding words.


Sometimes, a child who seems inflexible is struggling with transitions or unexpected changes.


Sometimes, a child who appears distracted is working incredibly hard to filter out sensory information.


Sometimes, a child who seems perfectly capable in one environment struggles substantially in another.


And sometimes, the things we initially interpret as behavioral concerns are actually signs that a child needs a different kind of support.


As adults, parents, educators, and mental health professionals, we have a responsibility to remain curious.


We should be asking questions.


We should be looking at the whole child.


We should be willing to learn about differences that we may not personally experience.


And we should be especially careful about making sweeping statements about conditions we may not fully understand. Juat because Matt Walsh doesn't acknowledge it, doesn't mean its not real.


Not every child needs the same interventions. Not every neurodivergent person has the same experiences. Not every neurodivergent individual identifies with the term neurodivergent, even.


That's precisely why individualized understanding matters.



So, Is Neurodivergence Real?


Yes.


Neurodivergence is an umbrella term, not a formal medical diagnosis itself. Its definition and boundaries are still evolving, and people don't universally agree on which conditions belong under that umbrella. But, that's okay. We clump lots of disorders into categories.


We don't have to agree on every label to acknowledge the experiences of the people using them.


We don't have to understand someone's brain to respect their needs.


And we certainly don't need to personally experience a disability to recognize that it exists.


Perhaps instead of spending so much time debating whether a word is legitimate, we could spend a little more time understanding the people that word is intended to describe. That's the care and compassion we need to truly change the world.


Because at the end of the day, we're not talking about a social media trend.


We're talking about real children, real adults, real families, real educational experiences, and real challenges.


And those people deserve more than a dismissive 60-second Reel.


If you're neurodivergent... I see you. Your struggles are valid. ADHD and autism are real. Dyslexia is real. And, if you have an intellectual disabilty, that's real and I'm so sorry a grown ass man called you that.


Compassion and kindness go a longggg way, Mr. Walsh.




Looking for Support? From people who don't invalidate your life experiences?

Therapy in Greensburg, PA


At Caring Conversations Therapeutic Services, LLC, we believe understanding people starts with recognizing that no two individuals experience the world in exactly the same way.


We offer in-person therapy in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, as well as secure online counseling to residents throughout Pennsylvania, including Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Harrisburg, Erie, Somerset, Lancaster, and surrounding communities.


We work with children, adolescents, and adults navigating anxiety, trauma, ADHD, depression, life transitions, and other mental health (and neurodivergent!) concerns.


Call or text 724.201.9815 to learn more or schedule a free consultation.


Healing happens here.





Disclaimer: This blog is written and maintained by non-clinical staff at Caring Conversations Therapeutic Services, LLC. Content is intended for general psychoeducation and opinion purposes only and should not be considered medical advice or a replacement for individualized therapy or professional evaluation. If you are experiencing a mental health emergency, call 911 or 988.

Comments


bottom of page